Lava Crab - 10man Ulduar (see notes)
Raid Zone:
Ulduar 10man
On the menu!
1) 2 (or 3) Tower Flame Leviathan.
2) Hard-mode XT002.
3) Kologarn.
4) Auriaya.
5) Hard-mode Hodir.
6) Cheeseball Thorim (so Pudo can get credit for Champ of Ulduar).
7) Cheeseball Freya (same as above).
8) Cheeseball Mimiron (fuck hardmode).
9) Cheeseball Vezax.
10) One Light in the Darkness.
It's ambitious and we may not pursue it this week given that we may not have people on Sunday. But let's wait and see before we make any hard decisions.
Thu, 07/02/2009 - 11:15
Thu, 07/02/2009 - 15:00
| 5 individuals signed up |
|---|
| Shihli |
| saedo |
| Nuitarin |
| Keisjaa |
| caramun |

Glory of the Ulduar Raider
saedo — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 22:27Parses: http://wowwebstats.com/oppfv4cju1qim
This is what I believe to be
saedo — Fri, 07/03/2009 - 13:10This is what I believe to be our Yogg kill: http://wowwebstats.com/oppfv4cju1qim?s=346636-382755
Interestingly, this is probably the most even split in dps I've ever seen. lol
fill in
caramun — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 17:39id be happy to fill in a dps spot if u guys are one short. thanks
There are a few things I'd
Disrupter — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 14:32There are a few things I'd like to discuss about our 10 man raid but I'm not sure how to get my opinion out without being an asshole or being smited by the almighty smiter that is anyone in our raid that completely disagrees.
Why are we raiding? Why do we raid? What is it we raid for? Do we do it for fun? For loot? For epeen status? What do you raid for?
I personaly have my reasons for raiding. My reasons for raiding are quite simple. I enjoy raiding, seeing my character and my raid progress. Doing new content we've never done before is generally my favorite part of this game, learning something together with my raid and finally getting the boss down.
I also enjoy reaping the benefits of our work, after finally beating a boss that took us a month or two of attempts to learn we can usually immediately begin farming said boss. Once we've done it once, we can generally repeat it with the same people and have a success at it.
(This is where I get to sound like an asshole and everyone hates me, so read on if you want :p)
Once we kill Yogg hardmode, that removes the "not done before" aspect of raiding, other then 1 hour, a very small amount of time, on Algalon. I do want to see him dead, but when we have so many upgrades from the same god damn instance, why aren't we going to do the hardmodes? Why is it when we are limited to one hour of attempts that we do not want to be at the best level we can when we do said attempts? If we wipe at one fucking percent how many of you will put 2+2 together that if we had put in that effort prior, we could of possibly gotten the kill that much sooner? Nothing will make me more upset if we flake and only do algalon, and we have a 1% wipe and we hadn't made the effort to better our selves.
On that same gear note, runed orbs and boes. Why do we keep our boes instead of depositing them in the bank yet we don't keep our runed orbs? Our runed orbs are boes that we have to piece together, and we have people IN OUR RAID that could use the runed orbs WE farmed. I know Garreth said for us to keep it but Garreth is not our raid leader or master looter so I'm going to voice my opinion clearly instead of being told my logic is fucking flawed in a whisper. We earned it, we keep it, we gear our raid. When we are done gearing up our raid I don't see why not share, I'm all for helping our 25 man progress (or as of now, catch the fuck up).
Basically I want to know what our plans are after we get Yogg 1 keeper over the next week or so. I'm not really all that into the idea of showing up for an hour or two at our normal show up time to do attempts on a boss if we're not going to put our full effort into doing the job right. Which includes:
My Basic Points:
1) Gearing our raid with the necessary runed orb items we need, we earned it, why not. If you want to call that logic flawed so be it, then my logic is flawed in your eyes, but my logic is very sound in my mind.
2) Gearing our raid with the necessary upgrades off hardmodes. If no one needs something off the boss then we should still do it hardmode, badges mean more gear for more options later. I want all of our classes that can do more then one roll to be geared and capable of doing their multiple jobs, or atleast two of the three if their class has more then two. Zildo (if he raided with us) should do good elemental dps AND healing. Moriella, you should be able to shadow it up at the bottom of the meters with Knoppix (lol I kid ilu knoppix <3), and our tanks should beable to do dps when we only need 1 tank , since we have THREE capable tanks, they should all have a dps set, not many fights we need all three.
3) Consider our future progression and raid make up. We , atleast I don't , know exactly what fights will need how many healers, tanks, or dps. We don't know if some fights a specific tank or healer will shine over others while specific dps classes will shine. Why not be prepared for the next content patch. We certainly farmed sunwell as much as we could knowing that all the gear we got was going to be replaced with blues and greens sometime near 76.
That's basically it, perhaps we can discuss this better over ventrilo while we faceroll through all the bosses we are doing on easy mode. Find out who wants what, of 9 out of 10 of our raiders don't want to continue doing the hardmodes we successfully did then that's fine atleast 90% of the people get what the fuck they want. But honestly, we farmed the fuck out of karazahn, farmed the fuck out of zul'aman, we continued to raid the hell out of tk/ssc even when we had Bt/Tk on farm. Why the hell would we skip out on content that is still fresh and new to us?
My views, even though we'll
Shihli — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 15:52My views, even though we'll openly discuss this tonite.
1) We can keep our orbs from now on. I know we weren't required to from the get-go, and I honestly felt that we'd do much more iwth them, as a guild, by putting them into the communal pool. I didn't think this was a huge deal though, at least not at first - for now, though, we'll hold onto our runed orbs from here on out.
2) I didn't say we weren't going to be forgetting about the whole of Ulduar10 - there's still some EXCELLENT loot to get from there. My whole point was that, if push came to shove, all we would feel "obligated" (for lack of a better word) to do per week was Algalon. Everything else is optional/fun/gearing and entirely up to the wants of our Lava Crab raid.
3) I propose we get a running list of all of the legitimate hard-mode upgrades from Lava Crab content and see what we can farm up before 3.2. First and foremost is drakes, though. Gear, we can get and we can replace. Drakes, we can't replace, nor can we get anytime.
We'll discuss it more on vent before raid.
My upgrades for
Desteran — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 15:42My upgrades for mainspec (offspec is currently hance, just need to upgrade some chants/gems and get those god-aweful expensive chants on my weapons):
[item]Ice Layered Barrier[/item] - Hodir
[item]Sif's Remembrance[/item] - Thorim
[item]Aesuga, Hand of the Ardent Champion[/item] - Vezax
[item]Meteorite Crystal[/item] - Algalon
[item]Observer's Mantle[/item] - Algalon (situational/sidegrade)
[item]Fire Orchid Signet[/item] - Freya (sidegrade really)
[Breastplate of the Stoneshaper] - XT (would probably just use this for Vezax)
So lets just hard mode those bosses and skip the rest...wait :-P
BIS
moriella — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 16:13The trinket IS probably BIS, but the other non algalon loot, is there not better in 25 man ?
I guess I should exand on my
Desteran — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 15:58I guess I should exand on my thoughts. As you all know I am burnt out for the most part. I am going to do my best to see this through to an Algalon kill (and some drakes of course). I could really care less about this piece of gear over that (it will get replaced sooner or later).
Well here's mine's in order
saedo — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 15:52Well here's mine's in order of dps importance:
[Drape of the Faceless General]: General Vezax, +82.2 dps - Best in Slot by a long shot. Twice as good as the 2nd best off Hodir 25 hard mode.
[Combatant's Bootblade]: Thorim, +74.9 dps - 2nd to BiS, which would be off Freya 25 man hard mode
[Mjolnir Runestone]: Thorim, +74.5 dps - BiS, nothing else comes close til 3.2
[Band of Lights]: Algalon, +51.7 dps - BiS, well for the 2nd ring slot. Not as huge compared to other upgrades
[Brann's Sealing Ring]: Algalon, +44.2 dps - Replacable with 25 man Algalon
[Dark Matter]: Algalon, +41.7 dps - Replacable with 25 man Algalon
[Loop of the Agile]: Iron Council, +41.5 dps - Replacable with above rings, and Algalon 25
[Serilas, Blood Blade of Invar One-Arm]: Freya, +39.0 dps - Best option for i232 level weapons unless I get above dagger first
[Soul-Devouring Cinch]: Yogg-Saron, +21.5 dps - Best in slot
[Caress of Insanity]: Yogg-Saron, +12.8 dps - Only usable if I get this before any other weapon upgrades
[Fluxing Energy Coils]: XT-002, +7.7 dps - Best in slot, but you can see it's not by much
[Gloves of the Endless Dark]: Algalon, +1.1 dps - Kinda sidegradish, would replace with other offsets easily
[Twirling Blades]: Flame Leviathan, +0.2 dps - Best in slot, but very small margin now.
[Pulsar Gloves] Algalon, One
Disrupter — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 17:36[Pulsar Gloves] Algalon, One of if not the best gloves (depends on what cloaks I can get...)
[Drape of the Messenger] Algalon, One of those cloaks I mentioned ;p.
[Starlight Treads] Algalon, trading haste for crit post 3.2 would be nice since I'm going to be using wrath alot more.
[Shimmering Seal] Flame Leviathan, A possible temp upgrade.
[Belt of the Crystal Tree] Iron Council, best resto bet I can find since I'm not getting the one with 6 orbs.
[Fire Orchid Signet] Freya, good upgrade for resto.
[Sif's Remembrance] Thorim, also strong resto upgrade.
[Leggings of Profound Darkness] Vezzax, Possibly useful for moonkin at some point, but more of an immediate resto use.
[Amice of Inconceivable Horror] Yogg, resto - and - moonkin upgrade. Though temporary for moonkin.
[Signet of Soft Lament] Yogg, resto/moonkin once again.
Most of them are either BIS or extremely difficult to replace. Alot of the moonkin upgrades are also upgrades for resto (go figure) And vice versa. But the point is ... this is the raid I enjoy as of late and if you take this from me then I have very little to want to sign in for (no, that's not a threat, just means when I sign on , im not WANTING to do some of the stuff I'm doing and I'm only doing it in the hopes that the situation gets a little bit better with time, someone has to put the effort forward to gear up 8 recruits ;p.)
response to rupta :)
moriella — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 15:04your points
1) I totally agree with your first point. I've not even bothered putting my name on the list to make another item as the way the system currently is it would take me seemingly months to 'earn' 6 more orbs. And I'll say it here, whoever the person was who decided orbs would be awarded/earned based on who can put their name on a post first, didnt think that one thru very clearly.
2) I've got 300ish badges and nothing to spend em on. I'm guessing it's about the same for most of our other raiders, unless they bought PVP gear.
3) Algalon drops absolutly positivly the best loot in game. With the drops we can get from him - honestly, is there that much more available in a 10 man instance that could contribute significantly?
4) Algalon can be done with all 226 level gear. He's been reported as a pretty easy boss, all things considered.
I think the stress of 25 and our lack of progression has burned/is burning many of us out for 10 man. I know I'm tired of 6 days a week. I think we are all looking at this as KB continuing at 4 days a week - it would be nice to have our 10 man at 1 day/week.
You cited evidence of how we used to farm content in BC. Yes, thats very true - however, we didnt farm it twice a week - the same instance over and over. You couldnt do kara in 10 and 25. Same for BC and SSC/TK. Doing the same content over and over in two groups is pretty boring frankly.
As for Algalon loot, it would
saedo — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 15:37As for Algalon loot, it would likely depend on the class.
For me, the sum total of Thorim Hard Mode loot are a larger upgrades than what I can get on Algalon. Would be nice to have both though of course.
Runed Orbs, I'll say this.
saedo — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 15:30Runed Orbs, I'll say this. Lava Crab has contributed a total of 9 orbs out of 135 collected. It's a drop in a bucket. One of us gets 1 extra piece. Or maybe just 9 of us having a single orb to hold.
This system is basically the same as the Sunmotes. Yea first come first serve, promote the use of the website. What's the alternative? In game whispers? Whoever whispers Garreth first? Or Loot Council, something we'd be opposed to as a concept. Or charge points? Quisjaa wanna do that? Sure not the best system, but no system can be perfect.
But honestly, none of these items are huge upgrades. You may argue Best in Slot, for some sure. But they're not hugely better than other i226 alternatives. Might be another story if they're i239 or something. 6000g of mats for a 10dps upgrade? Sure i'll do that, but I won't lose any sleep over not getting them, ever.
9 orbs
moriella — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 16:05That data has to be flawed. I've seen us get multiple orb drops from one boss on several occasions. The number of times we've killed FL on 2-4 towers up would have provided 9 orbs. We've been doing hard modes in ULD for months. Saying we only got 9 orbs is pretty unbelieveable.
We've killed way more bosses(total kills over x weeks)in 10 than we've killed in 25 and you are asking me to believe that our drop rate for orbs in 10 is lower than the fragment drop rate in 25.
My estimate comes from
saedo — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 16:17My estimate comes from this.
1 Orb drops form 2+ Tower FL. (3 tower gives patterns)
1 Orb drops from 2+ Elder Freya.
We killed FL 4 Tower once, 3 Tower once, 2 tower 5 times, 3 Elder once, 2 Elder once.
That's 9 possible drops.
The "multiple" orb drops are from 25 man. The stack of 2s with 1 extra. That's all been 25 man. The stack of 2s is the guarenteed drop from non-ezmodes. The extra 1 is the random kill boss drop.
9 orbs may not be 100%
Shihli — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 16:079 orbs may not be 100% accurate but it's not far off. Remember, they hotfixed in a mini-patch about ... oh, maybe a month or so ago that even allowed runed orbs to drop in 10man in the first place.
Regardless, we can't get back the orbs we got, but we'll keep the ones we get from now on.
with no KB on friday do we
Keisjaa — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 07:31with no KB on friday do we really need it all done in one night now?
To Algalon!
saedo — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 09:55To Algalon!
I'm w/ you except for
Desteran — Wed, 07/01/2009 - 10:00I'm w/ you except for cheesballing vezax :-D
Hmm our Hard Mode Vezax kill
saedo — Wed, 07/01/2009 - 10:06Hmm our Hard Mode Vezax kill took 6 mins.
Our last ez Vezax kill took 5 mins.
Let's do take that extra minute!
trying to get to yogg in one night
moriella — Wed, 07/01/2009 - 10:15Forget FL 2 or 3 towers. We need to one shot whatever we do. A wipe on FL will cost us 10-15 minutes for vehicles to respawn etc.
Vezax easy mode. This is the longest run in the game if we wipe. Odds of one shotting hard mode are very very low. We could easily delay ourselves by an hour if we try hard mode again.
We need to be on yogg by 9pm raid time at the latest. We are not gonna get there doing ANYTHING risky.
Only reason I say this is
Desteran — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 16:03Only reason I say this is because I need the vezax kill for my drake (yes I am a selfish :-P). While I'd like to look at one keeper Yogg tonight...unless it is easy beyond our wildest imaginations were probably gonna need a full night on it.
I don't think that'll be too
Shihli — Thu, 07/02/2009 - 16:05I don't think that'll be too hard to handle. Going to ask you guys if you wanna tackle the rest of Lava Crab tomorrow night since there's not going to be a KB raid.
Can prob do 3 towers at least
saedo — Mon, 06/29/2009 - 10:08Can prob do 3 towers at least easily.
Throw in IC hard mode cause Pudo's only there Thurs?